Cycloidal Drive (alternative)
Status: in progress / shelved
A live alternative, not built. Shelved for now because (1) its eccentric input mounts on the same motor-shaft D-flat that is our actual failure point, so it doesn't dodge the root cause, and (2) it needs a lot of extra pins + bearings. Kept on the table for its torque/shock advantage. TODO: prototype + measure.
Why it's interesting
Of all the options it holds the most output torque and tolerates shock best — a large fraction of the lobes press the ring pins at once, so a reversal spreads across many contacts instead of hammering one tooth. That is exactly the load that keeps shearing the planetary. It is also coaxial, low-backlash, and routinely 3D-printed.
Ratio
Single stage, ring fixed: reduction = number of lobes (with ring pins = lobes + 1). So 11 lobes / 12 ring pins → 11:1 in one compact stage — our whole target in one stage vs the planetary's two.
Components (printable build)
- Eccentric on the input shaft (a bearing on an off-centre hub) — makes the disc orbit. Use two discs 180° apart to balance it (one disc alone is an unbalanced spinning mass and shakes).
- Cycloidal disc(s) — printed: lobed edge + holes for the output pins + central bore for the eccentric bearing.
- Ring pins (outer) — fixed in the housing; count = lobes + 1. Steel dowels or bolts, ideally with a roller bearing over each.
- Output pins (inner) — on the output plate, through oversized holes in the disc (oversize = 2 × eccentricity); they pick off the slow rotation and ignore the orbit. ~6–8, with rollers.
- Bearings: one eccentric bearing per disc, a roller per ring/output pin (~18–20 small bearings), plus 2 main bearings for input and output.
- Output flange + shaft to the column; housing holds the ring pins.
The catch
The eccentric still mounts on the motor-shaft D-flat (same creep risk as the planetary's sun), and it is a lot of parts to keep concentric. TODO: decide whether the torque/shock gain is worth the component count once the planetary's material path (PPA / steel sun) is exhausted.
CAD
Not modelled yet
No CAD. If prototyped: model in Fusion, add a public-link embed + STEP, and a lobe-profile generator note (module, eccentricity, lobe count).